“It’s not what you say, it’s how you say it.”
Ever heard that? It’s time to rethink it.
In the arena of public discourse, few things are as insidious and destructive as tone policing.
It's a subtle weapon, often cloaked in the guise of civility, but it can stifle voices, derail important conversations, and perpetuate systemic inequities.
Understanding tone policing and its damaging effects is critical if we want to foster genuine, meaningful dialogue in our personal and public lives.
What Exactly is Tone Policing?
Tone policing occurs when someone focuses on the emotional delivery of a message rather than the message itself.
Instead of engaging with the substance of what’s being said, the tone police critique the speaker’s emotional expression—whether it's perceived as too angry, or too aggressive.
Imagine you’re in a heated discussion about social justice.
You passionately express your frustration about ongoing injustices, only to be met with, “Calm down, you’re being too aggressive.”
That’s tone policing in action. It diverts attention from the actual issue to how the issue is being discussed, effectively silencing valid concerns and experiences.
Why is Tone Policing Harmful?
1. Invalidates Emotions
Emotions are a fundamental part of human communication. When someone expresses anger or frustration, those emotions are valid and often rooted in real, lived experiences.
Tone policing dismisses these emotions as inappropriate or overblown, which can be deeply invalidating.
Consider a scenario where a survivor of abuse is sharing their story.
If someone responds by saying, “You’re being too dramatic, or too aggressive.” it invalidates the survivor’s pain and experiences.
This not only shuts down the conversation but also reinforces the survivor's sense of isolation and marginalization.
2. Stifles Important Conversations
Tone policing can derail crucial discussions by shifting the focus from the issue at hand to the speaker's delivery.
This tactic is often used to avoid uncomfortable truths or challenging topics.
By insisting on a 'proper' tone, important conversations about injustice, inequality, and other pressing issues can be silenced.
For instance, during the civil rights movements, activists were often told to moderate their tone to be heard.
This was a way to control and dilute their message, making it more palatable to those in power, but less urgent and impactful.
3. Perpetuates Power Imbalances
Tone policing often reinforces existing power dynamics.
It’s typically used by those in positions of privilege to silence marginalized voices.
By demanding that people soften their tone, the dominant group maintains control over the conversation and the narrative.
4. Undermines Authenticity
Genuine communication involves the free expression of thoughts and emotions.
Tone policing undermines this authenticity by imposing arbitrary standards on how people should express themselves.
It creates an environment where only certain types of communication are deemed acceptable, often those that align with the comfort levels of the privileged.
Examples of Tone Policing
Example: In a corporate setting, an employee passionately advocates for better training. The response from management?
“You need to present your ideas more calmly if you want us to listen.”
Here, the critique of tone undermines the urgency and importance of the issue raised.
Breaking the Chains of Tone Policing
1. Focus on the Message
Engage with the content of what’s being said rather than how it’s being said.
Ask yourself: What is the core issue being raised? Why is this important?
2. Reflect on Your Own Biases
Consider whether your discomfort with someone’s tone is rooted in unconscious biases.
Are you more likely to tone police individuals from different groups?
Reflecting on these biases can help you respond more thoughtfully.
3. Create Safe Places for Expression
Foster environments where people feel safe to express themselves authentically.
Encourage open dialogue where understanding is seen as integral to the conversation, not as a distraction.
Call to Action: Embrace Authentic Dialogue
Let’s commit to listening more deeply and responding more thoughtfully.
Next time you feel the urge to tone police, pause and refocus on the message.
Embrace the full spectrum of the conversation as a vital part of your own understanding.
Together, we can create a culture of authentic dialogue where every voice is heard and valued.
Challenge the status quo, question your own reactions, and strive to understand the deeper truths behind the conversation.
Only then can we hope to build a more understanding, and inclusive society.
No comments:
Post a Comment